The disadvantages of extrinsic motivation
Extrinsic motivation can be defined as any type of system proposed with the intent of rewarding some type of behaviour. Extrinsic motivation can cause detrimental effects on student achievement and closing the achievement gap. Authors of "Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation," Roland Benabou and Jean Tirole, state "contingent rewards serve as positive reinforces for a desired behaviour." Many educators use extrinsic motivation as a means for defining "good or appropriate" behaviour within the immediate learning environment--including as a reward when bad behaviour is corrected 1. Some examples of these rewards could be in the form of candy and food, extra break time, verbal praise, bonus points and money.
Many students will take advantage of the reward system. Students will tend to intentionally commit wrongful acts just to receive the reward that is offered when they correct this behaviour. This effort gives the instructor a false sense of success. The student is fully aware of his own actions. However, he will commit the offence just to have some issue he can solve to get the reward.
Fair and Unfair Practices
In a normal class size, there will always be one or two students who display negative actions and corrective action becomes necessary. When a student is placed on a coercive action plan in such a way that requires a reward system, the remaining students become aware of the situation.
Once the disruptive student begins to learn and act appropriately, they will receive rewards for their individual work in the learning environment. At this time, the remaining students tend to have a negative reaction. The reaction is primarily caused by the fact that the students who are in need of correction receive rewards, while the students who are behaving well receive nothing in return for their good behaviour. This action has a tendency to remove the good nature and morals from the remaining students, thus replacing their behaviour with negative actions.
Rewarding Bad Behavior
Students who receive reward plans for correcting bad behaviour tend to get confused as to why they are receiving such rewards. Many students on these reward plans feel as though their negative behaviour is what delivers a reward. At this point, the student feels as if this defines him as a person within the normal learning environment. Any deviation from this personality trait would defy the characteristics of his identity, thus removing him from his comfort zone within the classroom. The reward system simply promotes the behaviour of this type of student.
Extrinsic motivation can be beneficial, at least short-term, when properly implemented within the normal learning environment. It is important to remember that the effects of extrinsic motivation, without using the coercive practice of extinction, are only temporary in nature. The student will generally change the sporatic behaviour and traits therein until the reward period is over. Generally, the student will diverge his personality trait back to its initial status.
- Factors Affecting Moral Development
- Types of Misbehavior in Children
- Examples of Behavior Modification Plans
- Moral Development of Children in Early School Years
- The Pro & Cons of Behavior Modification
- Characteristics of Destructive Behavior in Children
- Pro & cons of violence in the media
- How to Raise a Child With a Type A Personality
- Short-Term Memory Loss in Teens
- How to Deal With Arrogant Children
- What Is Mental Abuse in a Marriage?
- Influence of Schools on Behavior of Children
- Desired Behaviors in Children
- The Effects of Telling a Child That He Is Stupid
- When Do Kids Learn Negative Numbers?
- "Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation: The Review of Economic Studies"; Roland Benabou and Jean Tirole; 2003
- schulanfang image by pdesign from Fotolia.com